EIR Grants Guide: Education Innovation & Research
Updated 10 official sources
Quick Answer: Education Innovation and Research (EIR) grants fund evidence-based education programs through three tiers: early-phase, mid-phase, and expansion.
Full answer and how we checked it
Early-phase grants were up to $6M in the FY2024 competition, mid-phase grants up to $10M in FY2025 (opens in a new tab), and expansion grants up to $15M in FY2025 (opens in a new tab). Each tier requires progressively stronger evidence, and every grantee must provide a 10% match from Federal, State, local, or private sources. As of October 9, 2026, no FY2026 EIR competition has been announced in the Federal Register. EIR replaced the former Investing in Innovation (i3) program and is the Department of Education's primary mechanism for building the evidence base for what works in education.
Who this is for: Education nonprofits, school districts with experimental programs, ed-tech companies partnering with research institutions, university-based education researchers, and charter management organizations with strong outcome data.
Data note: Award caps, match, and scoring come from the FY2025 EIR mid-phase and expansion notices (2025-17670 (opens in a new tab), 2025-17671 (opens in a new tab)) and the FY2024 early-phase notice (2024-09797 (opens in a new tab)), checked October 9, 2026.
In this guide
- How EIR Works: The Three-Tier Structure
- Early-Phase Grants: Testing New Approaches
- Mid-Phase Grants: Proving What Works
- Expansion Grants: Scaling Proven Programs
- The Match Requirement
- How Applications Are Scored
- Coordinating EIR with Other Federal Programs
- What ED.gov Doesn't Tell You
- FY 2026 Outlook
- Related Guides
- How Grantsights Checked This Guide
- Sources
EIR grants are the Department of Education's answer to a fundamental problem: we don't have enough rigorous evidence about what works in education, and the evidence we do have doesn't spread to enough schools. The program creates a pipeline where promising ideas get initial funding and evaluation, effective programs get resources to scale, and the whole field gets better research on what actually improves student outcomes.
If you've heard of the i3 program (Investing in Innovation), EIR is its successor under ESSA. The structure is similar: tiered grants that require progressively stronger evidence and support progressively larger investments. The difference is that ESSA codified the evidence requirements more explicitly and tied them to the same four-tier framework used across school improvement and other Title programs.
This guide covers how EIR works, what each tier requires, how to assess whether your program is ready to compete, and what the evaluation requirements actually mean in practice.
How EIR Works: The Three-Tier Structure
EIR is authorized under ESSA Title IV, Part F, Subpart 1, and housed in the U.S. Department of Education's Office of Elementary and Secondary Education (opens in a new tab). A 2025 ED-Department of Labor interagency agreement shifted grant administration for many OESE programs to DOL; check the next notice for which agency runs the competition. The program's defining feature is its tiered structure, which connects funding levels to evidence strength.
The Three Tiers at a Glance
| Tier | Maximum Award (latest notice) | Duration | Evidence Required | Match |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Early-Phase | $6M (FY2024) | Up to 60 months | Tier 4 (demonstrates a rationale) | 10% |
| Mid-Phase | $10M (FY2025) | Up to 60 months | Tier 2 (moderate) or Tier 1 (strong) | 10% |
| Expansion | $15M (FY2025) | Up to 60 months | Tier 1 (strong) | 10% |
The Evidence Pipeline Logic
The program is designed as a progression. Here's the idealized pathway:
- You have an idea. You develop a program with a strong theory of action and preliminary evidence (Tier 3 or 4). You compete for an early-phase grant.
- You build evidence. The early-phase grant funds implementation and a rigorous evaluation. If the evaluation produces positive results (Tier 2 evidence), you're positioned for the next tier.
- You scale. A mid-phase grant funds expansion to new sites with another evaluation. If that evaluation produces Tier 1 evidence, you compete for an expansion grant.
- You go wide. An expansion grant funds implementation across many sites, with a final evaluation confirming that the program works at scale.
In reality, few programs complete this full arc. The competitions are years apart, leadership changes, and the evidence doesn't always cooperate. But the framework shapes how the Department of Education thinks about education innovation.
Get grant deadline alerts by email
About once a week, we email a short list of open grant calls with real deadlines from different funders. It isn't limited to the programs in this guide.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Early-Phase Grants: Testing New Approaches
What Qualifies
Early-phase grants fund programs that have:
- A well-developed theory of action (logic model)
- At least one study showing promise (correlational with controls) OR a strong logic model with supporting research
- A plan for rigorous evaluation
- A realistic implementation plan
What Early-Phase Doesn't Require
You don't need a randomized controlled trial to compete for early-phase funding. You don't need to have served thousands of students. You do need a clear, logical connection between your program's activities and the outcomes you expect, supported by some form of evidence.
Common Early-Phase Projects
- New tutoring models tested in 10-20 schools
- Technology platforms for teacher professional development
- Social-emotional learning curricula in early grades
- Community-school partnerships addressing attendance
- Career pathway programs in high schools
Evaluation Requirements
Early-phase grantees must conduct at least a quasi-experimental evaluation. This means comparing outcomes for students or schools that participate in the program to a comparison group that doesn't. The comparison group doesn't have to be randomly assigned (that's what distinguishes quasi-experimental from experimental), but it must be carefully selected to minimize selection bias.
There's no fixed evaluation budget share in the notices, but underfunded evaluations produce weak evidence that doesn't help you compete for the next tier. Price the design with your evaluator before you set the rest of the budget.
Mid-Phase Grants: Proving What Works
What Qualifies
Mid-phase grants fund programs with:
- At least moderate (Tier 2) evidence (one well-designed quasi-experimental study showing positive effects), or strong (Tier 1) evidence
- A track record of implementation across multiple sites
- Organizational capacity to expand
- A plan for a more rigorous evaluation (typically an RCT)
The Evidence Threshold
Tier 2 evidence means you have at least one study that:
- Used a quasi-experimental design (comparison group, not necessarily random assignment)
- Found statistically significant positive effects on student outcomes
- Was conducted by a reasonably independent evaluator
- Has been documented in a peer-reviewed or publicly available report
If your only evidence comes from internal program reviews or reports without a comparison group, you don't meet the mid-phase threshold.
Common Mid-Phase Projects
- Expanding a proven literacy program from 20 schools to 100
- Scaling a successful STEM curriculum across a state
- Replicating a high-dosage tutoring model in new contexts
- Growing a teacher residency program with demonstrated retention effects
Evaluation Requirements
Mid-phase grantees should plan for a randomized controlled trial (RCT) or a very strong quasi-experimental design. The goal is to produce Tier 1 evidence. The FY2025 notice scores whether the evaluation, if well implemented, would meet What Works Clearinghouse standards without reservations.
Expansion Grants: Scaling Proven Programs
What Qualifies
Expansion grants are the top tier and have the highest bar:
- Tier 1 evidence (at least one well-designed RCT showing positive effects)
- Demonstrated implementation fidelity across multiple sites
- Organizational infrastructure to support large-scale expansion
- A plan for a multi-site RCT to confirm effects at scale
Why So Few Programs Qualify
Relatively few education programs have Tier 1 evidence. The What Works Clearinghouse (opens in a new tab) reviews thousands of studies, and most programs don't have the rigorous evaluation needed to clear the Tier 1 bar. Funded expansion applicants are usually organizations that have invested years in building their evidence base.
Award Sizes
Expansion grants are the largest in the EIR portfolio. The FY2025 expansion notice (opens in a new tab) capped awards at $15 million for a project period of up to 60 months. These are substantial investments, reflecting the Department's confidence that the program works and the expense of implementing it at scale with a rigorous evaluation.
The Match Requirement
EIR requires every grantee to put in a match. According to the FY2025 notices (opens in a new tab), section 4611(d) of the ESEA requires each grantee to provide an amount equal to 10 percent of the grant from Federal, State, local, or private sources, in cash or in-kind. The rate doesn't change by tier, and the Secretary may waive it case by case for exceptional circumstances.
| Tier | Match Required | Example at the latest cap |
|---|---|---|
| Early-Phase | 10% | $600,000 (for a $6M grant) |
| Mid-Phase | 10% | $1,000,000 (for a $10M grant) |
| Expansion | 10% | $1,500,000 (for a $15M grant) |
Applicants must include a budget showing their matching contributions and evidence of first-year match in the application.
How to Secure the Match
National foundations. Large education funders with research portfolios can be worth approaching, but confirm a foundation's current priorities before you count on it.
Corporate partners. Ed-tech companies, textbook publishers, and assessment companies sometimes provide matching funds or in-kind support for programs that align with their products or markets.
Local and regional foundations. For early-phase applicants, local community foundations and regional education funders may be more accessible than national funders.
State, local, and in-kind sources. Match can come from State or local funds and from documented in-kind support: donated technology, staff time, facilities. But in-kind must be carefully valued and documented per Uniform Guidance requirements.
Bottom line: Start securing match commitments 6-12 months before the application deadline. The match is often the bottleneck that prevents otherwise strong applications from being submitted. If a national foundation has expressed interest in your work, approach them about an EIR match early. Many foundations view EIR matches as an efficient use of their dollars because the federal grant multiplies their investment.
How Applications Are Scored
EIR applications are reviewed by external peer reviewers. The FY2025 mid-phase (opens in a new tab) and expansion (opens in a new tab) notices used four selection criteria worth 100 points:
| Criterion | Points (FY2025) |
|---|---|
| Significance | Up to 15 |
| Strategy to scale (includes the management plan) | Up to 35 |
| Quality of the project design | Up to 20 |
| Quality of the project evaluation or other evidence-building | Up to 30 |
Competitive preference priorities added up to 15 more points in FY2025. Criteria change by tier and year, so score yourself against the current notice.
What High-Scoring Applications Do
Clearly articulate the problem and the solution. Don't assume reviewers know your program. Explain what you do, why it works, and what evidence supports it, all in clear, jargon-free language.
Present a detailed logic model. Map the pathway from inputs to activities to outputs to outcomes. Show how each component of your program connects to the student outcomes you expect to improve.
Budget for implementation fidelity. Programs fail at scale not because the model is wrong but because implementation varies. Budget for training, monitoring, and quality assurance systems that ensure every site implements the program as designed.
Choose the right evaluator. The evaluator should have experience with IES-reviewed studies, familiarity with your content area, and capacity to conduct the required research design. Name the evaluator in your application and include their qualifications.
Be honest about limitations. Reviewers appreciate applicants who acknowledge challenges and describe mitigation strategies rather than pretending everything will go perfectly.
Coordinating EIR with Other Federal Programs
EIR grants can fund activities that overlap with other ESSA programs, but coordination is important to avoid duplication and maximize impact.
EIR + Title I
If your EIR-funded program operates in Title I schools, ensure that EIR funds supplement Title I activities rather than duplicating them. A tutoring program funded by EIR should be distinct from (or additive to) any tutoring funded by Title I in the same schools.
EIR + Title II-A
Title II-A funds support professional development. If your EIR program includes teacher training, coordinate with the district's Title II-A plan. EIR can fund the new training model; Title II-A can fund the ongoing coaching and support that sustains it.
EIR + School Improvement (1003(a))
Schools identified for CSI or TSI improvement must use evidence-based interventions. An EIR-funded program with Tier 1 or Tier 2 evidence is exactly what these schools need. Coordinate with state and district school improvement offices to align implementation.
EIR + IES Research Grants
IES (Institute of Education Sciences) also funds education research through its own grant programs. The difference: IES grants are pure research, focused on generating knowledge. EIR grants are implementation-focused, combining program delivery with evaluation. Some organizations hold both IES and EIR grants for different phases of their research agenda.
What ED.gov Doesn't Tell You
The Department of Education's EIR guidance covers program requirements thoroughly, but several practical realities deserve attention.
The evaluation will constrain your program. Conducting a rigorous evaluation (especially an RCT) means accepting research requirements that limit your flexibility. You can't change the program mid-stream without threatening the evaluation's validity. You can't expand to new sites that aren't in the evaluation design. You may need to maintain a control group that doesn't receive services, which creates ethical tension in communities with clear need. Discuss these tradeoffs with your evaluator before you apply.
The evaluation has to stand up publicly. The FY2025 notices require grantees to make the final evaluation report public and submit it to ERIC. A design that can't meet What Works Clearinghouse standards won't produce the evidence tier you need for the next competition.
The match still favors well-connected applicants. Organizations with strong funder relationships can line up a match more easily. If you don't have those ties, look at State and local sources, in-kind arrangements, and smaller regional foundations, and ask early whether your circumstances could support a waiver request.
Annual performance reporting is intensive. EIR grantees submit detailed annual performance reports covering implementation progress, evaluation milestones, match documentation, and preliminary findings. The Department has de-funded grantees that fell behind on implementation timelines. Build reporting capacity into your project team from the start.
Warning: Match documentation can be a bigger risk than the evaluation itself. Foundations that verbally commit to multi-year matches sometimes reduce or redirect their funding mid-grant when their own priorities shift. When that happens, the grantee has to find replacement match funding mid-implementation or face a finding. Document your match sources with signed letters of commitment at the time of application, not just letters of intent.
FY 2026 Outlook
As of October 9, 2026, no FY2026 EIR Notice Inviting Applications has appeared in the Federal Register. The most recent competitions were the FY2025 mid-phase and expansion competitions, published September 12, 2025, with applications due October 14, 2025. There's no open EIR competition to apply to right now.
The FY2025 notices show the current direction. Both used an absolute priority on evidence-based literacy, plus two competitive preference priorities from the Secretary's September 9, 2025 supplemental priorities:
- Returning Education to the States: projects carried out by State educational agencies, Tribes or Tribal educational agencies, or consortia of them (up to 10 points)
- Expanding Education Choice (High-Impact Tutoring) (up to 5 points)
According to ED's December 2025 announcement, the FY2025 competitions produced $256 million in new awards across 24 literacy grants. Watch the Federal Register (opens in a new tab) for the next notice before you plan a timeline.
Related Guides
How Grantsights Checked This Guide
Grantsights reviewed the Department of Education EIR program page, FY2025 EIR award announcement, the FY2024 early-phase and FY2025 mid-phase and expansion notices in the Federal Register, What Works Clearinghouse resources, and Grants.gov, most recently on October 9, 2026. Where official sources stop: ED explains EIR tiers and evidence expectations, but it does not tell applicants whether their program is ready for early-phase, mid-phase, expansion, a smaller pilot, or a non-EIR funding path.
| Source checked | What it confirms | Applicant decision |
|---|---|---|
| Department of Education EIR (opens in a new tab) | EIR purpose, ALN, office, and competition status | Confirm tier and current competition before drafting |
| FY2025 EIR awards release (opens in a new tab) | $256 million and 24 new literacy awards | Benchmark award patterns and priority fit |
| EIR early-phase page (opens in a new tab) | EIR tier structure | Use only when evidence level matches the tier |
| What Works Clearinghouse (opens in a new tab) | Evidence-review context | Check whether the program evidence is strong enough |
| Grants.gov (opens in a new tab) | Formal application package route | Confirm deadline, forms, and submission rules |
Decision checklist: identify evidence tier, evaluator, sample size, match source, implementation sites, data access, and sustainability before choosing an EIR tier.
According to the Department of Education, EIR supports field-initiated, evidence-based efforts that improve achievement and attainment for high-need students and requires rigorous evaluation. According to ED's December 15, 2025 award announcement, the Department awarded $256 million in new EIR grants across 24 literacy awards. According to ED's EIR page, ALN 84.411A/B/C covers the early-phase, mid-phase, and expansion structure. A common mistake is applying to mid-phase or expansion when the program's evidence doesn't meet that tier's threshold.
Our analysis of EIR grant readiness shows that evidence, match, and evaluation design decide the route. For example, a district with a strong logic model and limited outcomes data should usually target early-phase or a smaller pilot, while an organization with a prior quasi-experimental study may be ready for mid-phase. An ed-tech company without an independent evaluator, school data agreements, or private match is a bad fit for immediate EIR submission. Use this page with school improvement grants, Title I program records, education grants, Grantsights matches, and pricing.
Sources
- U.S. Department of Education, "Education Innovation and Research (EIR)," https://www.ed.gov/grants-and-programs (opens in a new tab)
- ESSA Title IV, Part F, Subpart 1, Sections 4611-4616
- Institute of Education Sciences, What Works Clearinghouse, https://ies.ed.gov/ncee/wwc/ (opens in a new tab)
- Federal Register, FY2025 EIR Mid-Phase notice inviting applications (2025-17670) (opens in a new tab)
- Federal Register, FY2025 EIR Expansion notice inviting applications (2025-17671) (opens in a new tab)
- Federal Register, FY2024 EIR Early-Phase notice inviting applications (2024-09797) (opens in a new tab)
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between EIR's three grant tiers?
Early-phase grants (up to $6M over 5 years in the FY2024 competition) fund new approaches with a strong logic model but limited existing evidence. Applicants need at least a Tier 4 evidence base (a rationale supported by research). Mid-phase grants (up to $10M over 5 years in FY2025) fund programs that already have evidence of effectiveness. Applicants need at least moderate (Tier 2) evidence, meaning at least one well-designed quasi-experimental study, or strong evidence. Expansion grants (up to $15M over 5 years in FY2025) fund scaling proven programs to new contexts. Applicants need Tier 1 evidence (at least one randomized controlled trial showing positive effects). The tiers create a pathway: a program that starts with an early-phase grant can build evidence through that evaluation, then compete for a mid-phase grant, and eventually scale with an expansion grant. Note that FY2025 held only mid-phase and expansion competitions, with no early-phase competition.
What is the match requirement for EIR?
Under ESEA section 4611(d), every EIR grantee must provide a match equal to 10% of the grant funds, from Federal, State, local, or private sources, in cash or in-kind. The rate is the same for every tier. For example, a $10 million mid-phase grant needs $1 million in match. Applicants must show a budget of matching contributions and evidence of first-year match in the application. The Secretary may waive the match case by case for exceptional circumstances. In-kind contributions must be documented and valued under the federal cost principles.
How competitive are EIR grants?
Very competitive. The FY2025 mid-phase notice estimated 8 to 15 awards, and the FY2025 mid-phase and expansion competitions shared an estimated $253 million. ED doesn't publish a standard success rate, so treat any single figure with caution. Applications are scored by peer reviewers on 100 points of selection criteria, and the FY2025 notices offered up to 15 more competitive preference points. Because preference points can decide close calls, check every priority in the current notice.
Does my organization need to conduct an independent evaluation?
Yes. All EIR grantees must include an independent evaluation conducted by a third-party evaluator. The evaluation design must be rigorous enough to produce evidence at or above the tier of the grant. Early-phase grantees must conduct at least a quasi-experimental study. Mid-phase grantees must conduct a randomized controlled trial or a strong quasi-experimental design. Expansion grantees must conduct a randomized controlled trial. The FY2025 notices require an independent evaluation and require grantees to make the final report public and submit it to ERIC, which IES runs. ED doesn't set a fixed evaluation budget share, so size it to the design. Identify your evaluator during the application process. In FY2025 the evaluation criterion was worth up to 30 of 100 points.
Can EIR grants fund technology-based programs?
Yes. EIR grants have funded numerous education technology programs, including adaptive learning software, virtual tutoring platforms, teacher coaching apps, and data analytics tools. Technology-based programs are neither favored nor disfavored; they're evaluated on the same evidence standards as any other approach. The advantage of technology programs in the EIR context is that they're often easier to scale (a software platform can be deployed in many schools simultaneously), which aligns well with mid-phase and expansion grant goals. The challenge is demonstrating that the technology itself drives outcomes rather than the training, support, and implementation structures around it. Strong EIR tech applications clearly articulate what the technology adds beyond what traditional approaches can achieve.
Last updated October 9, 2026. Corrected October 9, 2026: what changed. Published by Grantsights from public sources. See our editorial policy, how we build and check guides, corrections and how we make money.
Related Guides
Complete Guide
Federal Grants for Nonprofits 2026: Where to Apply
Federal grants for nonprofits 2026: nonprofits got $42.7B in direct federal grants in FY2025, $25.4B from HHS. How to register, apply, and win subgrants.
McKinney-Vento Grants: Homeless Education Guide
McKinney-Vento EHCY is funded at $129M for 1.5 million homeless students. Learn liaison duties, transportation rights, and how subgrants work.
Best Grant Research Tools for Nonprofits 2026
Best grant research tools for nonprofits 2026: Grantsights, Instrumentl, Candid, and GrantWatch compared. Pricing, features, and who each is built for.
Grants for Adult Education Programs 2026: GED and ESL
Grants for adult education programs in 2026: AEFLA got $715 million in FY2025, and 428 foundations gave to adult literacy and ESL groups on 990-PFs.
Grants for Arts Education 2026: 758 Funders Found
Grants for arts education in 2026: 758 foundations filed 1,804 grants worth $55.5 million for school arts programs. See who gave, how much and why.
Grants for Education Nonprofits 2026: Top Funds
56,392 private foundations made education grants on recent 990-PFs. Find 12 federal programs open to nonprofits, plus 10 education funders for 2026.