Formula Grants vs Competitive Grants Explained
Updated 16 official sources
Quick Answer: Formula grants are split by a formula in law, not by scoring proposals: Congress provided $18.4 billion for Title I, Part A in FY2025, and the Department of Education divided it among states mainly by Census poverty counts, according to the Congressional Research Service report on FY2026 appropriations.
Full answer and how we checked it
Competitive grants, such as NIH R01s, are scored against other applicants under a published funding notice. Grantsights analysis of USAspending FY2025 data found block and formula grants carried 78% of federal grant dollars, while project grants and cooperative agreements made up 65% of individual awards.
Data note: This guide was checked against current SAM.gov Assistance Listings, Grants.gov, 2 CFR 200, USAspending award data, HUD and BJS allocation files, and Congressional Research Service appropriations reports on October 17, 2026. Current statutes, appropriations, program notices, and state subaward rules control each funding path.
Source review by Grantsights, October 17, 2026: Federal portals define programs and award types, but a prospective applicant must still identify the actual recipient and open application route. A small nonprofit should not prepare a direct federal proposal for a state-administered formula allocation before checking the state administering agency's current subaward process.
In this guide
- The Core Difference: Allocation vs Competition
- Formula Grants vs Competitive Grants: Comparison Table
- How Much Federal Grant Money Is Formula vs Competitive?
- How Formula Grants Work
- How Competitive Grants Work
- Block Grants: The Hybrid Category
- Five Programs, Five Routes: Title I, CDBG, WIC, Ryan White Part B and Byrne JAG
- Mandatory vs Discretionary: Another Way to Slice Federal Grants
- Earmarks and Congressionally Directed Spending
- Pass-Through Mechanics: How Formula Grants Reach Local Organizations
- Which Type Should You Pursue?
- Related Guides
- What State Grant Administrators Don't Tell You
- Sources
If you're a state or local official, a school district, a tribe, or a nonprofit trying to figure out which federal funds are allocated and which you have to win, this guide breaks down the key differences with FY2025 and FY2026 numbers.
If you work in grants, you'll hear these two terms constantly: formula grants and competitive grants. They're the two primary ways the federal government distributes grant funding, and they work in very different ways. Confusing them can lead you to waste time writing proposals for money that's already allocated, or, worse, to ignore funding you're entitled to.
This guide breaks down exactly how each type works, who can access them, how the application processes differ, and where the real money flows. We'll use five real programs and current dollar figures so you can see these differences in practice. For a broader orientation to how federal grants work across all program types, our complete federal grants guide covers the full picture.
Where official sources stop: the common mistake is treating a formula-program description as an open direct-funding opportunity. First identify the primary recipient and confirm whether the administering state or local agency has an active subaward, procurement, or formula-allocation route. If it does not, do not apply to the federal listing as though it were a competitive NOFO.
The Core Difference: Allocation vs Competition
Formula grants allocate money to eligible recipients based on criteria set by Congress. If you meet the eligibility requirements, you receive your calculated share. You don't compete against other applicants. In FY2025, for example, the Byrne Justice Assistance Grant (JAG) program split $302.0 million among states, territories and 1,649 eligible local governments using population and violent crime counts, according to the Bureau of Justice Statistics JAG 2025 technical report (opens in a new tab).
Competitive grants (also called discretionary grants or project grants) award money based on the quality of your application. A federal agency reviews and scores proposals, ranks them, and funds the highest-scoring applications until the money runs out. There's no guarantee that any applicant will receive funding.
Federal award data uses four labels for grants. In USAspending.gov (opens in a new tab) records, assistance type 02 is a block grant, 03 a formula grant, 04 a project grant, and 05 a cooperative agreement. Project grants are the classic competitive route. Cooperative agreements are usually competed too, but 2 CFR 200.1 separates them from grants because the agency expects substantial involvement in the work. Each program's Assistance Listing on SAM shows which type it is, under "Types of Assistance."
This distinction affects everything: who can apply, how you apply, how much you receive, and how certain you can be about getting funded.
Looking for your next grant?
About once a week, we email a short list of open grant calls with real deadlines from different funders. It lists open calls only.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Formula Grants vs Competitive Grants: Comparison Table
| Feature | Formula Grants | Competitive Grants |
|---|---|---|
| How funds are distributed | Statutory formula (population, poverty, enrollment, etc.) | Merit-based review and scoring |
| Who decides the amount | Congress sets the formula; data determines allocations | Agency reviewers score applications; agency makes awards |
| Guarantee of funding | Yes, if eligible and compliant | No, depends on application quality and available funds |
| Typical recipients | State governments, local governments, school districts, tribes | Nonprofits, universities, state/local agencies, individuals |
| Application type | State plan or administrative application | Full proposal with narrative, budget, evaluation plan |
| Competition level | Non-competitive (administrative review) | Highly competitive (NIH R01-equivalent success rate was 13.0% in FY2025) |
| Award size predictability | Predictable year-to-year | Varies based on proposal and funding availability |
| Funding duration | Ongoing, typically annual | Fixed project period (1-5 years, with possible renewals) |
| FY2025 federal obligations | $969.6 billion in block and formula grants (Medicaid alone was $666.0 billion) | $275.4 billion in project grants and cooperative agreements |
| Number of awards with FY2025 activity | 177,124 | 323,295 |
| Examples | Medicaid, Title I, TANF, IDEA, WIC, CDBG, Byrne JAG | NIH R01, NSF research grants, SAMHSA discretionary |
Source: obligations and award counts are Grantsights analysis of USAspending FY2025 data (method below).
How Much Federal Grant Money Is Formula vs Competitive?
Grantsights analysis of USAspending.gov (opens in a new tab) FY2025 award data found $1.24 trillion in federal grant obligations, and 78% of it moved through block and formula grants. Method: we queried the USAspending API's spending-over-time and award-count endpoints once for each assistance type code (02, 03, 04 and 05) for October 1, 2024 through September 30, 2025, then split out Medicaid (Assistance Listing 93.778) using the same API's by-program totals.
| Assistance type (code) | FY2025 obligations | Share of dollars | Awards with FY2025 activity | Share of awards |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Block grant (02) | $729.0 billion | 58.6% | 8,267 | 1.7% |
| Formula grant (03) | $240.6 billion | 19.3% | 168,857 | 33.7% |
| Project grant (04) | $218.9 billion | 17.6% | 276,821 | 55.3% |
| Cooperative agreement (05) | $56.4 billion | 4.5% | 46,474 | 9.3% |
| Total | $1,245.0 billion | 100% | 500,419 | 100% |
Three findings matter for applicants:
- Medicaid distorts the headline. Medicaid grants to states were $666.0 billion, 91% of all block grant dollars. Take Medicaid out and the remaining $579.0 billion splits about 52% formula or block and 48% project or cooperative agreement. Outside Medicaid, competitive money is nearly half the pie.
- Competitive awards are smaller and far more numerous. The average block or formula award with FY2025 activity carried about $5.5 million in obligations; the average project grant or cooperative agreement carried about $0.85 million.
- The type code doesn't always match how the money is split. Ryan White Part B (93.917) is allocated mostly by a statutory formula, yet all $1.29 billion of its FY2025 obligations are coded as project grants. Byrne JAG (16.738) is a formula program, yet most of its FY2025 obligations are coded as block grants. Check the program's authorizing law or NOFO, not just the data label.
Caveats: these are obligations recorded in FY2025, net of any deobligations, not appropriations. Programs funded in advance, like Title I, show money from more than one appropriation year. Award counts include continuing awards that had any FY2025 transaction, not only new awards. Some grants coded under newer financial assistance codes (F001 and F002) are excluded; together they held under $0.1 billion in FY2025.
How Formula Grants Work
Formula grants use a mathematical formula written into the authorizing legislation to determine how much each eligible recipient receives. Congress defines the formula, appropriates the total funding, and the administering agency calculates each recipient's share using current data. For Byrne JAG, BJS weights violent crime and population 50/50 and guarantees every state at least 0.25% of the total, which was $755,110 in 2025, per the BJS technical report.
The Formula Components
Every formula grant uses specific data points to calculate allocations. Common formula factors include:
- Population: Total state or county population (used in CDBG, Byrne JAG and many transportation grants)
- Poverty rate: Number or percentage of people below the federal poverty level (used in Title I, Head Start)
- Per capita income: State income relative to the national average (used in Medicaid's FMAP calculation)
- Enrollment data: Student enrollment counts, child counts for special education (used in IDEA, Title I)
- Housing data: Age of housing stock, overcrowding rates (used in CDBG)
- Disease or caseload counts: Living HIV cases drive Ryan White Part B base awards
- Crime data: A 3-year average of violent crime reported to the FBI (used in Byrne JAG)
- Unemployment rates: State or local unemployment data (used in Workforce Innovation and Opportunity Act programs)
- Road miles and vehicle miles traveled: Used in Federal Highway Administration formula programs
How the Money Flows
Here's the typical path for formula grant dollars:
- Congress appropriates funds for the program (for example, $18.4 billion for Title I in FY2025 and $18.43 billion in FY2026).
- The federal agency applies the formula using the most recent available data (Census poverty estimates, enrollment counts, etc.) to calculate each state's allocation.
- The state submits a plan to the federal agency describing how it will use and distribute the funds.
- The federal agency reviews the plan for compliance (not competitiveness) and approves the allocation.
- The state distributes funds to local recipients (school districts, local agencies) using a state-level formula or competitive process.
- Local recipients use the funds according to program rules and report on outcomes.
The critical point: at the federal-to-state level, there's no competition. The formula determines your share. At the state-to-local level, the state may use its own formula (passing funds through automatically) or run a competitive process for a portion of the funds.
Major Formula Grant Programs
| Program | FY2025 Obligations | Formula Basis | Primary Recipients |
|---|---|---|---|
| Medicaid (Title XIX) | $666.0B | Per capita income (FMAP) | State Medicaid agencies |
| Highway Planning and Construction | $60.6B | Road miles, VMT, lanes | State DOTs |
| CHIP | $20.5B | Enhanced FMAP | State health agencies |
| Title I, Part A | $18.2B | Census poverty data | State education agencies, then LEAs |
| TANF | $17.0B | 1996 spending levels | State human services agencies |
| IDEA Part B | $14.0B | Child counts, poverty | State education agencies, then LEAs |
| WIC | $7.5B | FNS food and administrative grant formula (7 CFR 246.16) | State WIC agencies, then local clinics |
| CDBG (entitlement communities) | $2.0B | Population, poverty, housing | Entitlement cities and counties; states for smaller communities |
Source: Grantsights analysis of USAspending FY2025 obligations by Assistance Listing. Obligations differ from appropriations because of advance funding, timing and reallocations.
How Competitive Grants Work
Competitive grants (discretionary grants) award funding based on the merits of an individual application. The federal agency publishes a Notice of Funding Opportunity (NOFO), organizations submit proposals, reviewers score them, and the agency funds the top-scoring applications. In FY2025, those project grants added up to $218.9 billion across 276,821 awards with activity, according to USAspending data.
The Application Process
Competitive grants follow a structured process that often takes many months from announcement to award; the NOFO usually lists the anticipated award date:
- The agency publishes a NOFO on Grants.gov describing the program purpose, eligibility, evaluation criteria, and application instructions.
- Applicants prepare proposals including a project narrative, budget and budget justification, organizational capacity description, evaluation plan, and supporting documents.
- Peer reviewers score applications using the criteria published in the NOFO. Most agencies assign more than one independent reviewer to each application.
- The agency makes funding decisions based on reviewer scores, geographic distribution, portfolio balance, and policy priorities.
- Awards are negotiated and issued. Selected applicants may need to revise budgets or work plans before receiving a formal award notice.
Success Rates
Competitive grants are, by definition, competitive. Success rates vary widely by agency and program:
- NIH R01-equivalent grants: 13.0% success rate in FY2025 (5,471 awards from 42,022 applications), per NIH success-rate data (opens in a new tab)
- NSF research grants: funding rates vary by directorate and year; check NSF's current funding-rate tables before quoting a figure
- SAMHSA discretionary grants: varies by program; the NOFO lists the anticipated number of awards
- Department of Education discretionary grants: varies widely, and some programs fund only a small share of applicants
These success rates mean that strong applications can still go unfunded due to limited budgets. Reviewers may score your application highly, but if there isn't enough money to fund all highly-scored proposals, you won't receive an award.
Major Competitive Grant Programs
| Program | Typical Award Size | Duration | Primary Applicants |
|---|---|---|---|
| NIH R01 | $250K-$500K/year | 3-5 years | Universities, research institutions |
| NSF Standard/Continuing | $100K-$500K total | 1-5 years | Universities, nonprofits |
| SAMHSA Discretionary | $200K-$2M/year | 3-5 years | States, nonprofits, tribes |
| DOJ/OJP Competitive | $150K-$1M/year | 1-3 years | State/local agencies, nonprofits |
| ED Innovation Grants | Varies widely | 3-5 years | School districts, nonprofits, states |
| USDA NIFA Competitive | $50K-$500K | 1-4 years | Universities, nonprofits |
Block Grants: The Hybrid Category
Block grants sit between pure formula grants and competitive grants. Like formula grants, block grants distribute funds to states using a statutory formula. But like competitive grants, the end use of block grant dollars often involves a competitive process at the state level. Outside Medicaid, block grants carried $63.0 billion in FY2025 obligations, led by TANF ($17.0 billion) and the Child Care and Development Block Grant ($8.6 billion), according to USAspending data.
How Block Grants Work
Congress creates a block grant program for a broad functional area (community development, social services, workforce development) and distributes funding to states or entitlement communities using a formula. The recipients then have significant flexibility in how they spend the money within that functional area.
The key distinction from categorical formula grants: block grants give recipients broader spending discretion. Title I money must be spent on improving education for low-income students. CDBG money can be spent on a wide range of community development activities, from housing rehabilitation to public infrastructure to economic development, as long as at least 70% of funds benefit low- and moderate-income people.
Major Block Grant Programs
- CDBG (Community Development Block Grant): HUD's FY2026 formula allocations total $3.30 billion across 1,303 states, cities and counties, per HUD's FY2026 CPD formula allocation page (opens in a new tab). States re-grant their portion to non-entitlement communities, often through competitive rounds. Our CDBG guide covers eligible activities.
- TANF (Temporary Assistance for Needy Families): $16.5 billion distributed to states based on 1996 spending levels, per the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities. States decide how to split funds across cash assistance, work programs, childcare, and other services.
- SSBG (Social Services Block Grant): Roughly $1.7 billion distributed to states by population formula. States use funds for a wide range of social services including child welfare, adult protective services, and disability services.
- SABG (Substance Abuse Block Grant): $1.70 billion in FY2025 obligations, distributed by SAMHSA to states based on multiple factors. States use funds for prevention and treatment services, often sub-granting to local providers through competitive processes.
Five Programs, Five Routes: Title I, CDBG, WIC, Ryan White Part B and Byrne JAG
These 5 programs show how differently "formula" money behaves once it leaves Washington. Grantsights checked each program's current funding level against the official appropriations or allocation source on October 17, 2026.
| Program (Assistance Listing) | FY2025 | FY2026 | Who gets the federal award | How local groups reach it |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Title I, Part A (84.010) | $18.407B appropriated | $18.427B appropriated | State education agencies | School districts get formula subgrants; no proposal contest |
| CDBG (14.218 / 14.228) | $3.299B in formula allocations | $3.300B in formula allocations | 1,200+ entitlement cities, counties and states | Nonprofits apply to the city or state as subrecipients |
| WIC (10.557) | $7.597B appropriated | $8.200B appropriated | State WIC agencies | States fund local clinics and agencies |
| Ryan White Part B (93.917) | $1.29B obligated | Ryan White total held at $2.571B | State health departments | States contract with clinics and AIDS service groups |
| Byrne JAG (16.738) | $302.0M allocated | FY2026 local solicitation due November 3, 2026 on Grants.gov | State administering agencies and eligible local governments | Ineligible localities and nonprofits apply to the state |
Sources: Title I and Ryan White totals from the Congressional Research Service report on FY2026 Labor-HHS-Education appropriations (opens in a new tab); WIC from the CRS report on FY2026 Agriculture appropriations (opens in a new tab); CDBG from HUD allocation spreadsheets; Ryan White Part B obligations from USAspending; JAG from BJS.
Title I, Part A. Congress kept Title I-A at $18.407 billion in FY2025 and raised it by $20 million to $18.427 billion in FY2026 in P.L. 119-75, according to the CRS report. For example, California received $2.25 billion in Title I obligations through its Department of Education in FY2025, the largest state share in USAspending records. Districts don't write competitive proposals for that money; they file a plan and get their calculated share. More detail is in our Title I guide.
CDBG. HUD's FY2025 spreadsheet allocates $3.299 billion in CDBG, and the FY2026 spreadsheet allocates $3.300 billion. For example, Chicago received a $74.1 million CDBG allocation for FY2026, down from $74.5 million in FY2025, per HUD's allocation files. A small change in a city's share of poverty or old housing moves its number even when the national total is flat.
WIC. WIC is a discretionary appropriation that's split by formula. Congress raised it from $7.597 billion in FY2025 to $8.2 billion in FY2026 in P.L. 119-37, according to the CRS report. The California Department of Public Health had $1.24 billion in FY2025 WIC obligations, the largest of any state agency in USAspending records.
Ryan White Part B. Part B mixes both routes. The base award follows a formula driven by living HIV cases, and one-third of the non-ADAP Part B money is reserved for supplemental grants that states compete for, per the CRS overview of the Ryan White program (opens in a new tab). The program's overall $2.571 billion level didn't change from FY2025 to FY2026, according to the CRS report on FY2026 appropriations. Our Ryan White program guide covers the other parts.
Byrne JAG, formula versus discretionary. JAG is formula money: BJS gives each state 60% of its allocation and sets aside 40% for local governments, and in 2025 the largest local allocations were New York City ($4.1 million), Los Angeles ($2.2 million) and Chicago ($1.8 million), according to the BJS report. The similarly named Byrne Discretionary Community Project Grants work nothing like that. BJA's FY2024 solicitation (Assistance Listing 16.753) offered $277,518,000 only to applicants invited because their project appeared in the congressional joint explanatory statement. "Discretionary" here means congressionally directed, not open competition.
Mandatory vs Discretionary: Another Way to Slice Federal Grants
The formula/competitive distinction overlaps with, but isn't identical to, the mandatory/discretionary distinction. Understanding both helps you predict funding stability. WIC shows the difference: it's split by formula, but it's discretionary, so its $8.2 billion FY2026 level depended on Congress passing the Agriculture appropriations act in November 2025.
Mandatory spending is required by law, and funding continues automatically unless Congress changes the authorizing statute. Medicaid, CHIP, and SNAP are mandatory programs. Their funding isn't subject to the annual appropriations process (though specific funding levels may be set in authorizing legislation).
Discretionary spending must be approved by Congress through annual appropriations bills. If Congress doesn't pass an appropriations bill (or passes a continuing resolution instead), discretionary programs may be funded at reduced levels or face delays. Both formula grants and competitive grants can be discretionary. Full-year FY2026 Labor-HHS-Education funding wasn't signed until February 3, 2026, more than four months into the fiscal year, according to the CRS report.
Here's where it gets tricky:
- Medicaid is mandatory and formula-based (guaranteed funding, allocated by FMAP formula)
- TANF is mandatory and formula-based (guaranteed at $16.5B/year, allocated by 1996 formula)
- Title I is discretionary and formula-based (funding depends on annual appropriations, but allocated by formula once funded)
- NIH R01 grants are discretionary and competitive (funding depends on annual appropriations and merit review)
For applicants, the practical takeaway: mandatory formula programs are the most predictable funding sources. Discretionary competitive programs are the least predictable because both the total funding amount and your individual award depend on annual decisions.
Earmarks and Congressionally Directed Spending
Since FY2022, Congress has revived earmarks (now called "Congressionally Directed Spending" in the Senate and "Community Project Funding" in the House). These are a third category worth understanding. The Byrne Discretionary Community Project Grants above are one example: $277,518,000 in FY2024, open only to the projects Congress named.
Earmarks bypass both formula allocation and competitive review. A member of Congress requests funding for a specific project in their district, and if the appropriations committee includes it in the spending bill, the funding is directed to that specific recipient. In FY2024, Congress directed billions of dollars in earmarks across thousands of individual projects; the Congressional Research Service tracks the annual totals.
For grant seekers, this means another funding pathway: contact your members of Congress during the annual earmark request period (typically January through March) and submit a request for a specific project. Many nonprofits and local governments have received earmark funding for infrastructure, community facilities, and program operations. Even after an earmark is enacted, you still file a full application with the agency, and the agency checks it against the project as written in the explanatory statement.
This pathway is separate from both the Grants.gov competitive process and formula allocations. It's a political process, not an administrative one.
Pass-Through Mechanics: How Formula Grants Reach Local Organizations
One of the most misunderstood aspects of formula grants is the pass-through process. Most formula grant dollars don't stay at the state level. The $18.2 billion in FY2025 Title I obligations went to just 55 recipients, almost all of them state education agencies that then subgrant to thousands of districts, according to USAspending records. The money flows down to local governments, school districts, nonprofits, and other organizations through subawards.
Here's how it typically works:
- The federal agency sends funds to the state. Under 2 CFR 200.1 (opens in a new tab), the state becomes a "pass-through entity" when it makes a subaward to carry out part of a federal program, and the organization that receives it is a "subrecipient."
- The state decides whether you're a subrecipient or a contractor. 2 CFR 200.331 (opens in a new tab) makes this a case-by-case call based on the substance of the relationship, not the label on the agreement.
- The state issues subawards to local recipients, by formula or through a competitive process. Under 2 CFR 200.332 (opens in a new tab), it must first check the SAM exclusion records to confirm you're not barred, evaluate your fraud and noncompliance risk, and put 14 federal award data elements in the subaward, including the FAIN and the Assistance Listing number.
- Subrecipients use the funds and report to the state. The state monitors you, consolidates reports and reports to the federal agency.
- Subrecipients follow federal rules. Even though you received your funds from the state, you're spending federal money. That means the Uniform Guidance applies: equipment thresholds of $10,000, the de minimis indirect cost rate of 15% of MTDC, sub-award reporting for each first-tier subaward of $30,000 or more in federal funds (per 2 CFR 170 (opens in a new tab)), and Single Audit requirements if your total federal expenditures reach $1,000,000.
Grantsights checked the subaward-reporting rule against 2 CFR 170 on October 9, 2026: the threshold is $30,000, not the $50,000 figure that still circulates (that number belongs to a different MTDC rule). The compliance obligations for subrecipients are essentially the same as for direct federal grant recipients. The state may add additional requirements, but it can't waive federal ones. Our subrecipient monitoring guide and Single Audit guide cover what the state will check.
Insider tip: Many organizations don't realize they're receiving federal pass-through funds. If your grant comes from a state agency but the award notice references a CFDA number (now called an Assistance Listing number), it's federal money flowing through the state. That triggers federal compliance requirements, including audit requirements. This is a common compliance trap.
Which Type Should You Pursue?
The answer depends on what kind of organization you are. Outside Medicaid, about 48% of FY2025 grant dollars went through competitive-style project grants and cooperative agreements, so most organizations need both routes:
If you're a state or local government agency: You're likely eligible for both formula and competitive grants. Prioritize formula grants first because they provide stable, predictable funding. Then layer competitive grants on top for specific projects and initiatives.
If you're a school district: You probably already receive formula funding through Title I, IDEA, and other education programs. Make sure you're claiming your full allocation. Then pursue competitive grants from the Department of Education and foundations for new programs.
If you're a nonprofit: Most of your direct federal grant opportunities will be competitive. However, don't ignore pass-through formula funding. Check with your state agencies and your city's CDBG office to see if they subgrant formula or block grant dollars to nonprofits. TANF workforce programs, SSBG-funded social services, SABG-funded substance abuse programs, and Ryan White Part B services all commonly subgrant to nonprofits. To see which open programs fit your organization, run the free Grantsights eligibility check.
If you're a university or research institution: Competitive grants (NIH, NSF, DOE) are your primary pathway. Formula grants rarely go directly to universities, though some education formula programs flow through states to higher education institutions.
If you're a tribal government or organization: You're eligible for many formula programs that include tribal set-asides (TANF, IDEA, CDBG Indian Set-Aside). You're also eligible for competitive grants through most federal agencies. The BIA and IHS also administer grant programs specifically for tribal entities.
Related Guides
What State Grant Administrators Don't Tell You
Formula allocations often arrive months late. HUD posted FY2026 CDBG allocations only after the FY2026 budget was enacted on February 3, 2026, more than four months into the fiscal year, per HUD's allocation page. BJA released the FY2025 State JAG solicitation on March 13, 2026, with a Grants.gov deadline of April 7, 2026, more than five months after FY2025 had ended, according to the BJA FY2025 State JAG solicitation (opens in a new tab). In 2025, the Department of Education also held back several July 1 formula payments (Title I-C, II-A, III-A, IV-A and IV-B) for weeks before releasing them, according to the CRS report. "Guaranteed" means guaranteed once appropriated, not guaranteed on time. Budget a cash cushion if a formula subaward pays your staff.
Competitive grants within formula-funded programs are where the real opportunity lies. Some formula programs reserve a share of funds for competitive or targeted awards. Title I's section 1003 school improvement set-aside (which replaced the old School Improvement Grants program under ESSA) lets states reserve 7% of their Title I allocation and award it to districts by formula or competition. Ryan White Part B reserves one-third of its non-ADAP money for competitive supplemental grants. WIOA's National Dislocated Worker Grants are another example. Applicants often miss these because they're announced by the state or the agency, not on the main formula page.
Formula data lags behind reality. JAG uses a 3-year average of violent crime reported to the FBI, and Title I relies on Census poverty estimates that trail the school year. If your community has experienced rapid population change, your allocation lags behind it.
A red flag in subaward agreements: if a state's subaward doesn't list the Assistance Listing number and FAIN, ask for them before you sign. 2 CFR 200.332 requires both, and without them you can't report the funds correctly on your Schedule of Expenditures of Federal Awards.
Sources
- USAspending.gov award search (opens in a new tab) and its public API, for FY2025 obligations and award counts by assistance type and Assistance Listing
- Congressional Research Service: Labor, HHS, and Education FY2026 Appropriations (R48970) (opens in a new tab) for Title I and Ryan White funding levels and the FY2025 forward-funding delay
- Congressional Research Service: Agriculture FY2026 Appropriations (R48564) (opens in a new tab) for WIC funding levels
- Congressional Research Service: Ryan White HIV/AIDS Program overview (R44282) (opens in a new tab) for the Part B formula and supplemental grant split
- HUD: FY2026 CPD Formula Program Allocations (opens in a new tab) and the FY2025 allocation spreadsheet for CDBG amounts
- Bureau of Justice Statistics: Justice Assistance Grant (JAG) Program, 2025 (opens in a new tab) for JAG allocations
- BJA: FY2025 State JAG solicitation (opens in a new tab) and BJA FY24 Byrne Discretionary Community Project Grants solicitation (opens in a new tab) for JAG timing and the earmark track
- eCFR: 2 CFR 200.332, Requirements for pass-through entities (opens in a new tab) for subaward rules
- Grants.gov Grant Programs (opens in a new tab) for federal grant program types and descriptions
- Department of Transportation: Grants Overview (opens in a new tab) for formula vs competitive grant definitions
- Tax Policy Center: Types of Federal Grants (opens in a new tab) for block grant and categorical grant explanations
- USDA NIFA: Types of Federal Assistance (opens in a new tab) for formula and competitive grant examples
- Center on Budget and Policy Priorities: TANF Block Grant (opens in a new tab) for TANF funding data
Frequently Asked Questions
What is an example of a formula grant?
Title I, Part A is one of the largest federal formula grants. Congress provided $18.4 billion for it in FY2025 and $18.43 billion in FY2026, according to the Congressional Research Service. The Department of Education calculates allocations with four statutory formulas driven mainly by Census poverty estimates, and states pass the money to school districts. Districts don't compete against each other for this money. If they meet the eligibility rules and file the required plan, they receive their calculated share.
Can nonprofits receive formula grants?
Nonprofits rarely receive formula grants directly from the federal government. Formula grants typically go to state governments, local governments, tribal entities, and school districts. However, nonprofits can reach formula dollars as subrecipients. A city that receives a CDBG allocation from HUD, or a state that receives a TANF block grant, may subaward part of it to nonprofits that run housing, workforce, or family support programs. The nonprofit applies to the state or city, not to the federal agency. This pass-through route is how most nonprofits access formula-based funding.
Do you have to apply for formula grants?
Yes, but the application is different from a competitive grant proposal. Formula grant recipients must submit a state plan or application that describes how they'll use the funds and shows they meet eligibility requirements. The application is reviewed for completeness and compliance, not scored against other applicants. As long as you meet the criteria and submit the required documents, you receive your allocation. Byrne JAG is a good example: BJA still posts a formal solicitation each year, but the award amount is the one the Bureau of Justice Statistics calculated by formula.
What percentage of federal grants are competitive vs formula?
Grantsights analysis of USAspending.gov data for FY2025 found about $1.24 trillion in grant obligations: block grants $729.0 billion (58.6%), formula grants $240.6 billion (19.3%), project grants $218.9 billion (17.6%) and cooperative agreements $56.4 billion (4.5%). Medicaid alone was $666.0 billion of the block grant total. Leave Medicaid out and the split is close to even: about 52% formula or block and 48% project grants or cooperative agreements. By count, project grants and cooperative agreements made up 65% of the awards with FY2025 activity.
What is the difference between a block grant and a formula grant?
A block grant is a type of formula grant with broader spending flexibility. Both use statutory formulas to allocate funds. The difference is how tightly the money can be used. A categorical formula grant like Title I restricts funds to a specific purpose (improving education for low-income students). A block grant like CDBG gives recipients a pot of money for a broad functional area (community development) and lets them decide which specific activities to fund within that area. Block grants trade federal control for local flexibility.
Last updated October 17, 2026. Corrected October 17, 2026: what changed. Published by Grantsights from public sources. See our editorial policy, how we build and check guides, corrections and how we make money.
Related Guides
Complete Guide
Federal Grant Proposal Guide: Sections & Scoring
Federal grant proposals average 50-100 pages. This guide covers every section and scoring criteria for writing a proposal that reviewers score highly.
Cal Grant 2027-28: Amounts, Income Limits, March 2 Deadline
Cal Grant A pays up to $15,588 at UC and $6,838 at CSU for 2026-27. See A, B and C amounts, 2027-28 income limits, and the March 2, 2027 deadline.
California SNAP Income Limits 2026-27: CalFresh Chart
CalFresh (California SNAP) income limit for a family of 4 is $5,500 a month gross (200% of poverty) from Oct 2026, with no asset test for most.
CalWORKs 2026: Grant Amounts, Eligibility, How to Apply
CalWORKs is California's cash aid for families with children. From October 1, 2026 a family of 3 with no income gets up to $1,196 a month in Region 1.
Car Payment Assistance 2026: Real Help, Not Grants
Few grants pay car loans. Real 2026 options: lender extensions, TANF diversion up to $2,000 in Washington, a 6% SCRA rate cap and repossession rights.
Car Repair Assistance 2026: Real Help, Not Free Grants
No federal grants pay for your car. Real help: TANF crisis funds, job center support, VA's $27,908.90 vehicle allowance and California smog repair aid.