Indirect Cost Rate Negotiation: NICRA Guide
Updated 12 official sources
Quick Answer: A Negotiated Indirect Cost Rate Agreement (NICRA) is a legal document between your organization and the federal government that sets the percentage you can charge for overhead on federal awards.
Full answer and how we checked it
You get one by submitting a detailed rate proposal to your cognizant agency, which a first-time nonprofit must do within 3 months of its award's effective date. Without a current NICRA, you can elect a de minimis rate of up to 15%.
This guide is for: CFOs, grants managers, sponsored research officers, and nonprofit executives deciding whether to stay with the 15% de minimis rate or prepare a negotiated indirect cost rate proposal.
Data note: Regulatory thresholds and requirements reflect the 2024 Uniform Guidance revision (effective October 1, 2024) per 2 CFR Part 200. Verify current requirements at ecfr.gov (opens in a new tab).
In this guide
- What a NICRA Is and How It Works
- Determining Your Cognizant Agency
- Building Your Indirect Cost Rate Proposal
- The Four Rate Types Explained
- The Negotiation Process: Step by Step
- De Minimis 15% vs. Negotiated Rate: When to Negotiate
- How Rate Changes Affect Existing Awards
- Related Guides
- What the NICRA Process Doesn't Tell You About Timing and Risk
- How Grantsights Checked This Guide
- Sources
Free post-award templates
Indirect cost (MTDC) calculator (Excel)
It builds the modified total direct cost base, counts only the first $50,000 of each subaward and applies your rate or the 15% de minimis.
Want the other three too? Personnel activity (effort) record, Drawdown reconciliation log, Budget change prior-approval check.
Every federal grant recipient pays overhead costs that don't tie directly to a single project: rent, utilities, IT support, accounting, HR, insurance, and general administration. These indirect costs are real, and the federal government recognizes that you should be able to recover them from your federal awards.
The question is how much you can recover. If you don't negotiate a rate, you're stuck at the de minimis rate of 15% (opens in a new tab) of modified total direct costs (MTDC). For many organizations, especially universities and large nonprofits, actual indirect costs far exceed that. University facilities and administrative (F&A) rates commonly range from 40% to 65% or higher.
This guide walks you through the entire NICRA process: determining your cognizant agency, building your rate proposal, understanding the four rate types, and navigating the negotiation itself.
What a NICRA Is and How It Works
A NICRA is a formal agreement between your organization and the federal government, establishing the indirect cost rate you can charge on federal awards. Once your cognizant agency approves the rate, all other federal agencies must accept it under 2 CFR 200.414 (opens in a new tab). You negotiate once, and that rate applies across the board.
The rate itself is a percentage calculated by dividing your total allowable indirect costs (the numerator) by a direct cost base (the denominator). The most common base is modified total direct costs (MTDC), which includes all direct salaries and wages, fringe benefits, materials, supplies, services, and travel. MTDC excludes equipment (items at or above the lesser of your capitalization level or $10,000 per unit), the portion of each subaward above $50,000, rental costs, participant support costs, and certain other items.
For example, if your organization has $500,000 in allowable indirect costs and $1,000,000 in MTDC, your indirect cost rate would be 50%.
Why the NICRA Matters Financially
The difference between the de minimis 15% rate and a negotiated rate can be substantial. Consider an organization with $2 million in annual direct costs across federal awards:
- At 15% de minimis: $300,000 in indirect cost recovery
- At 35% negotiated rate: $700,000 in indirect cost recovery
- At 55% negotiated rate: $1,100,000 in indirect cost recovery
That's $400,000 to $800,000 per year in additional revenue to cover real costs your organization is already incurring. Over a five-year award period, a properly negotiated rate can mean millions of additional dollars.
For a deeper look at calculating your rate, see our guide on how to calculate your indirect cost rate.
For the awards you already manage
Yearly plan
Grantsights Pro
$199a year
About $16.58 a month, or $24 month to month
Every award's report due dates and tasks in one place, with reminders before each date.
- Each award's report due date, amount and next step
- Task reminders 30, 14 and 3 days before each date, and a calendar feed
- Up to 3 people on one plan
Determining Your Cognizant Agency
Your cognizant agency for indirect costs is the federal agency responsible for reviewing, negotiating, and approving your rate on behalf of all federal agencies. Getting this right is the first step, because submitting your proposal to the wrong agency wastes months.
How Cognizance Is Assigned
2 CFR 200.1 (opens in a new tab) doesn't set the rule itself; it points to the appendix for your organization type. For a nonprofit, Appendix IV C.2.a names the agency with the largest dollar value of directly funded awards, unless the agencies concerned agree to a different arrangement. For institutions of higher education, 2 CFR 200 Appendix III (opens in a new tab) C.11 assigns cognizance to HHS or DOD's Office of Naval Research, depending on which provided more funding over the most recent three years, with HHS as the default.
Common cognizant agency assignments:
| Organization Type | Typical Cognizant Agency |
|---|---|
| Research universities (biomedical focus) | HHS (Cost Allocation Services, in the Program Support Center) |
| Research universities (defense/engineering focus) | Office of Naval Research (ONR) |
| Nonprofits (health/human services) | HHS |
| Nonprofits (other) | Agency with largest direct awards |
| State and local governments | Federal agency per Appendix V |
The cognizant agency assignment doesn't change unless there's a shift in the dollar volume of directly funded federal awards that persists for at least three years, according to Appendix IV to 2 CFR 200.
Important: your cognizant agency for indirect costs and your cognizant agency for audit (the agency responsible for overseeing your Single Audit if you spend over $1 million in federal awards annually) may be different agencies.
Looking for your next grant?
About once a week, we email a short list of open grant calls with real deadlines from different funders. It lists open calls only.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Building Your Indirect Cost Rate Proposal
The rate proposal is the foundation of your negotiation. A complete, well-organized proposal speeds up the process. An incomplete one adds months of back-and-forth.
What to Include
According to the Department of Labor's Guide for Indirect Cost Rate Determination (opens in a new tab) and agency-specific guidance, your proposal should contain:
- Cost policy statement: A narrative describing your organization's cost accounting practices, how you distinguish direct from indirect costs, and your methodology for allocating costs
- Organizational chart: Showing the structure of your organization and where indirect cost functions sit
- Financial statements: Most recently audited financial statements, including the schedule of federal awards (SEFA)
- Indirect cost rate calculation: The actual mathematical computation showing your indirect cost pool divided by your direct cost base
- Cost allocation plan: If your organization has multiple programs or departments, a plan showing how shared costs are allocated
- Supporting schedules: Detailed breakdowns of each cost category in both the indirect cost pool and the direct cost base
- Certificate of indirect costs: A signed certification that the proposal is accurate and complies with applicable regulations
Direct vs. Indirect Cost Pools
Getting the pools right is where most proposals stumble. Costs must be consistently treated as either direct or indirect. You can't charge a cost directly to awards sometimes and include it in your indirect cost pool other times.
Common indirect cost categories:
- Administrative salaries (executive director, CFO, HR, accounting staff not directly serving awards)
- Office rent and utilities for administrative space
- General office supplies and items below your equipment threshold
- Organizational insurance
- IT infrastructure and support
- Audit and legal fees (for general organizational purposes)
- Depreciation on buildings and equipment used for general operations
Costs that must be direct:
- Salaries of staff working directly on federal awards
- Materials and supplies purchased specifically for a project
- Travel directly related to award activities
- Equipment purchased for a specific project (at or above the lesser of your capitalization level or $10,000 per unit)
- Subcontracts and consultant fees for award-specific work
Common Issues That Slow Down Proposals
Based on feedback from cognizant agencies, these issues delay negotiations:
- Inconsistent cost treatment: Charging the same type of cost as both direct and indirect across different awards
- Unallowable costs in the indirect pool: Including costs that are explicitly unallowable under 2 CFR 200 Subpart E (entertainment, alcohol, lobbying, fines, and penalties)
- Space cost allocation problems: Not properly documenting how facility costs are allocated between federally funded and non-federally funded activities
- Depreciation methodology errors: Using incorrect useful life estimates or including fully depreciated assets
- Missing or outdated audit reports: Not providing current audited financial statements
The Four Rate Types Explained
Under 2 CFR 200 Appendix IV (opens in a new tab), there are four types of indirect cost rates. Understanding the differences is important because the rate type affects how adjustments work and how much financial risk your organization carries.
Provisional Rate
A provisional (or billing) rate is a temporary rate used for funding, interim reimbursement, and financial reporting while you work toward a final rate for that period. Think of it as an estimate that will be trued up later.
- When it's used: During the current fiscal year, before actual costs are known
- Adjustment: Must be adjusted to a final rate after the period ends
- Risk: If your actual costs come in lower than the provisional rate, you'll owe money back. If they come in higher, you can recover the difference.
Final Rate
A final rate is based on actual, audited costs for a completed fiscal year. It's applied retroactively to replace the provisional rate for that period.
- When it's used: After the fiscal year closes and actual costs are determined
- Adjustment: Not subject to further adjustment
- Risk: No risk of under- or over-recovery for the covered period
Predetermined Rate
A predetermined rate is set in advance for a specific future period, based on projected costs. Once established, it's not adjusted even if actual costs differ from the projections.
- When it's used: For organizations with stable, predictable cost structures
- Adjustment: No retroactive adjustments
- Risk: If costs increase beyond projections, you absorb the difference. If costs decrease, you keep the savings.
Fixed Rate with Carry-Forward
A fixed rate is set in advance like a predetermined rate, but any difference between estimated and actual costs is carried forward as an adjustment to a future period's rate calculation.
- When it's used: When both parties want rate certainty for the current period but want to correct for variances over time
- Adjustment: Differences are carried forward, not applied retroactively
- Risk: Self-correcting over time, but individual periods may have over- or under-recovery
Most nonprofits use provisional/final rate combinations. Universities typically use predetermined rates for their F&A negotiations.
The Negotiation Process: Step by Step
Here's what the negotiation looks like from start to finish. The regulation sets your filing deadlines but not the agency's review time, so the step durations below are planning estimates, not rules.
Step 1: Prepare Your Proposal (1-3 Months Before Submission)
Gather your financial data, develop your cost allocation methodology, and build the rate calculation. For first-time proposals, consider engaging a consultant or CPA firm with NICRA experience. The upfront investment typically pays for itself many times over through increased indirect cost recovery.
Step 2: Submit to Your Cognizant Agency
New awardees that haven't previously negotiated a rate must submit their proposal within 3 months of the effective date of their first federal award, according to 2 CFR 200 Appendix IV. Organizations with an existing NICRA must submit a new proposal within 6 months after the close of their fiscal year.
Submit your proposal to your cognizant agency's designated office. For HHS, that's Cost Allocation Services (CAS) in the Program Support Center, which takes proposals through its online portal. For NSF, proposals go through the NSF indirect cost rate proposal process (opens in a new tab). Each agency has specific submission instructions.
Step 3: Agency Review (2-4 Months)
The cognizant agency's rate negotiator will review your proposal, check for compliance with 2 CFR 200 cost principles, and verify your calculations. Expect questions. Common areas of inquiry include:
- How you distinguish direct from indirect costs
- Your methodology for allocating space costs
- Treatment of depreciation and use allowances
- Whether any unallowable costs are included in the pool
- How executive compensation compares to IRS thresholds
Step 4: Negotiate and Resolve Differences
If the agency disagrees with elements of your proposal, you'll go back and forth. This might involve providing additional documentation, adjusting your methodology, or removing certain costs from the indirect pool. All concerned federal agencies have the opportunity to participate in the negotiation, though in practice it's usually just the cognizant agency.
Step 5: Sign the Agreement
Once both parties agree on the rate, the cognizant agency issues the NICRA. This is a signed document specifying the rate type, the effective period, the distribution base, and any special conditions. Keep this document accessible because you'll need to include it with every federal grant proposal.
For details on how indirect costs fit into your overall grant budget, see our federal grant budget categories guide.
De Minimis 15% vs. Negotiated Rate: When to Negotiate
Under 2 CFR 200.414(f), any organization without a current federal negotiated indirect cost rate (including a provisional rate) can elect to charge a de minimis rate of up to 15% of MTDC. This option exists to reduce administrative burden for smaller organizations.
When the De Minimis Rate Makes Sense
- Your organization is small with limited overhead costs
- You receive less than $500,000 in annual federal funding
- Your actual indirect costs are close to 15% of MTDC
- You don't have the administrative capacity to prepare a rate proposal
- You're a new grantee and want to start simple
When You Should Negotiate
- Your actual indirect costs exceed 15% of MTDC (most established organizations)
- You receive significant federal funding (over $1 million annually)
- You have substantial facility costs, IT infrastructure, or administrative overhead
- The gap between 15% and your actual rate represents meaningful revenue
Can You Switch Between Rates?
Once you negotiate a rate, you use it while it's current. Because 200.414(f) bars only organizations that have a current negotiated rate (including a provisional one), you can choose not to renegotiate when your NICRA expires and elect de minimis from then on. You can't use both at once, and once you elect de minimis, 200.414(f) says you use it on all federal awards until you choose to receive a negotiated rate. Tell your cognizant agency before you let a rate lapse.
How Rate Changes Affect Existing Awards
When you negotiate a new rate, you need to understand how it applies to awards that are already in progress.
Awards with Provisional Rates
If an existing award was budgeted using a provisional rate, the final rate (once negotiated) replaces it. This can result in either additional funds owed to you or funds you need to return, depending on whether the final rate is higher or lower.
Awards with Predetermined Rates
Predetermined rates don't change retroactively. If you had a predetermined rate of 50% when an award was made, that rate holds for the agreed-upon period even if your new negotiated rate is 55%.
New Proposals and Continuations
For new proposals and competitive renewal applications, use your most current negotiated rate. Federal agencies expect to see the rate from your current NICRA in proposal budgets.
Agency Rate Caps
Some federal programs cap the indirect cost rate regardless of what your NICRA says. 2 CFR 200.414(c)(1) allows a different rate when a federal statute or regulation requires it or when the awarding agency approves one under 200.414(c)(3), and the NOFO has to disclose that policy. USDA NIFA (opens in a new tab), for example, says its indirect cost limits are set by regulation or statute and tells applicants to follow the limit stated in each NOFO. The National Endowment for the Humanities (opens in a new tab) provides its own indirect cost rate guidance for NEH awards. Always check the Notice of Funding Opportunity (NOFO) for any rate restrictions before submitting your proposal. For guidance on reading NOFOs, see our NOFO guide.
Related Guides
- NEH Grants
- Indirect Cost Rate Negotiation
- How to Write a Cost Allocation Plan for Grants
- 2 CFR 200.1 Definitions and Uniform Guidance
Effort Reporting Under 2 CFR 200.430, and What It Means for Your NICRA
Personnel cost documentation is directly connected to whether your indirect cost rate proposal holds up under scrutiny, and it's often misunderstood. The records-based standard in 2 CFR 200.430 dates to the 2014 Uniform Guidance, which replaced the semiannual effort certification that OMB Circular A-21 had required of universities; the October 2024 revision kept that approach. That doesn't mean you don't have to document effort. It means your organization can design its own documentation system as long as it's supported by internal controls and produces reliable records that support what you charged to federal awards. For organizations with NICRAs, that shift matters because your rate proposal's personnel cost methodology has to align with whatever documentation system you actually use. If your rate proposal describes a personnel activity report system you stopped running three years ago because you converted to a real-time timesheet system, your proposal has a consistency problem. A negotiator at HHS Cost Allocation Services, or at whichever agency is cognizant for you, can ask about the gap.
If an institution switches timekeeping systems without updating the rate proposal narrative and the negotiator spots the mismatch, that doesn't necessarily kill the negotiation, but it can add months to the review and require supplemental documentation showing that the actual costs in the indirect pool match what the proposal describes. That's a preventable delay: don't assume a working internal system is good enough without verifying that the proposal language matches.
The de minimis rate also changed in the 2024 revision. It moved from 10% of MTDC to 15% of MTDC, which is a meaningful increase for small organizations that qualify. If you were previously using 10% because that's what the regulation said and you hadn't negotiated a rate, you can now bill at 15% on federal awards without going through the NICRA process. For a nonprofit billing $800,000 in MTDC annually, that's an additional $40,000 in indirect cost recovery per year that requires no negotiation. Organizations that haven't reviewed their rate situation since before 2024 are leaving that money on the table.
The practical implication is that before you submit a NICRA proposal or update an existing rate, you need to do two things. First, verify that your personnel cost documentation system in the proposal matches what you're actually doing, not what you were doing when you last submitted a proposal. Second, confirm whether your actual indirect costs have crossed a threshold where negotiation makes financial sense once you account for the staff time a proposal takes and for however long your cognizant agency's queue is running.
What the NICRA Process Doesn't Tell You About Timing and Risk
The part of NICRA negotiations that catches organizations off guard isn't the math. It's figuring out which federal agency is supposed to negotiate with you and then waiting for that agency to actually do it. Your cognizant agency assignment matters because each agency's rate office (HHS's is Cost Allocation Services) operates differently. HHS handles most health and social service nonprofits. DOI covers tribal organizations. DOL picks up workforce-focused groups. If you submit your rate proposal to the wrong agency, you'll spend weeks getting redirected before the clock even starts on the real review. Organizations can lose an entire grant cycle by not confirming cognizance before submitting.
Backlogs can leave a proposal in queue for many months, and if you bill at a provisional rate that turns out lower than the final negotiated rate, reconciling the under-recovery can mean adjustments across fiscal years and multiple awarding agencies.
The practical lesson is to start the NICRA process at least 12 months before you need the negotiated rate in a proposal budget. Call your cognizant agency's cost allocation office before you submit anything and ask about current processing times, required formats, and the name of the regional contact who will handle your case. Organizations that treat the NICRA as a one-time paperwork exercise get burned. Those that build a relationship with their rate negotiator and submit clean, complete proposals on schedule give the review its best chance of moving quickly. The under-recovery risk from provisional billing alone makes this worth prioritizing.
How Grantsights Checked This Guide
Grantsights reviewed the current eCFR text, DOL cost-rate guidance, NSF indirect-cost proposal instructions, and our federal award records in June 2026. Where official sources stop: official pages explain the 15% de minimis rate and proposal mechanics, but they do not tell a nonprofit CFO when negotiation beats the simple route.
| Source checked | What it confirms | Applicant decision |
|---|---|---|
| 2 CFR 200.414 (opens in a new tab) | De minimis rate, negotiated-rate acceptance, and rate restriction rules | Start with the legal ceiling before budgeting |
| 2 CFR Part 200 Appendix IV (opens in a new tab) | Nonprofit indirect-cost proposal timing and cognizant agency process | Calendar the proposal before the fiscal year closes |
| Department of Labor cost determination office (opens in a new tab) | Agency review expectations for indirect cost proposals | Build the file the negotiator will actually review |
| NSF indirect cost proposal guidance (opens in a new tab) | NSF proposal review path and required schedules | Match the proposal format to the cognizant agency |
According to OMB at 2 CFR 200.414, organizations without a current federal negotiated rate may charge up to 15% of MTDC without negotiation. According to 2 CFR Appendix IV to Part 200, a first-time nonprofit indirect cost proposal is due within 3 months after the effective date of the federal award. According to DOL, rate proposals need a cost policy statement, financial statements, organization chart, and supporting schedules. According to NSF, indirect cost proposal review is a separate process from proposal merit review, so the rate file should be managed as its own workstream.
Our analysis of NICRA readiness patterns shows that the decision usually turns on annual MTDC volume, documentation quality, and whether a rate gap of 10 to 20 percentage points changes recovery enough to justify maintaining the file.
Bad fit check: do not start a NICRA negotiation just because a new award allows indirect costs. If your organization has one $180,000 federal award, limited shared administration, and actual overhead near 15%, the de minimis route may be the cleaner decision. For example, an organization with $2 million in MTDC and a supportable 35% actual rate can change recovery by $400,000 per year, while an organization with $150,000 in MTDC changes recovery by only $30,000 before staff time and audit exposure. Use this guide with the cost allocation plan guide, allowable costs guide, indirect cost calculator guide, and the Grantsights grants database before deciding whether a negotiated rate belongs in your next proposal.
Sources
- 2 CFR 200.414 - Indirect Costs (opens in a new tab)
- Appendix IV to Part 200 - Indirect Cost Rate Determination for Nonprofit Organizations (opens in a new tab)
- A Guide for Indirect Cost Rate Determination - Department of Labor (opens in a new tab)
- NSF Indirect Cost Rate Policies (opens in a new tab)
- Indirect Costs - USDA NIFA (opens in a new tab)
- Appendix III to Part 200 - Indirect (F&A) Costs Identification and Assignment, and Rate Determination for Institutions of Higher Education (opens in a new tab)
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a NICRA and why do I need one?
A Negotiated Indirect Cost Rate Agreement (NICRA) is a legal document between your organization and the federal government that establishes the percentage you can charge for indirect costs (also called facilities and administrative or F&A costs) on federal awards. Without a current NICRA, you can elect a de minimis rate of up to 15% of modified total direct costs under 2 CFR 200.414(f). Organizations with substantial federal funding often have actual indirect costs well above 15%, so a NICRA lets you recover a rate that reflects your real overhead. Under 200.414(c)(1), federal agencies must accept your negotiated rate unless a statute, a regulation, or an agency-approved deviation sets a different rate for a program, so you negotiate once with your cognizant agency.
How long does it take to negotiate an indirect cost rate?
2 CFR 200 doesn't set a deadline for the agency to finish its review, so the length depends on your cognizant agency's workload and how complete your proposal is. What the regulation does fix is your filing date: under Appendix IV C.2.b, a nonprofit without a rate must submit its first proposal no later than 3 months after the effective date of the federal award, and under C.2.c, an organization that already has a NICRA must submit a new proposal within 6 months after its fiscal year closes. Ask your cognizant agency's rate office for its current processing time before you count on a new rate.
What's the difference between the de minimis rate and a negotiated rate?
The de minimis rate is a rate of up to 15% of modified total direct costs (MTDC) that an organization without a current negotiated rate (including a provisional rate) can elect without negotiation, under 2 CFR 200.414(f). A negotiated rate is based on your organization's actual indirect costs and is typically higher than 15% for organizations with significant infrastructure. University F&A rates commonly range from 40% to 65% or more. The de minimis rate is simpler but may leave substantial money on the table. Once you negotiate a rate, you can't switch back to de minimis unless your NICRA expires and you choose not to renegotiate.
Who is my cognizant agency for indirect costs?
2 CFR 200.1 points to the appendices for the rule. For a nonprofit, Appendix IV C.2.a makes it the agency with the largest dollar value of awards directly funded to you, unless the agencies agree to a different arrangement, and the assignment doesn't change unless that dollar volume shifts for at least three years. For a university, Appendix III C.11 assigns either HHS or DOD's Office of Naval Research, based on which provided more funding over the most recent three years, with HHS as the default. Importantly, your cognizant agency for indirect costs may be different from your cognizant agency for audit.
How do rate changes affect my existing federal awards?
When you negotiate a new rate, the effect on existing awards depends on the rate type. Awards made under a provisional rate are adjusted when the final rate is established. Awards made under a predetermined rate are not adjusted retroactively. Fixed rates carry forward the difference between estimated and actual costs as an adjustment to a future period's rate. For new proposals, you should always use your most current negotiated rate. Some agencies cap indirect cost rates on certain programs regardless of your NICRA, so check the funding announcement carefully.
Last updated October 13, 2026. Corrected October 13, 2026: what changed. Published by Grantsights from public sources. See our editorial policy, how we build and check guides, corrections and how we make money.
Related Guides
Indirect Cost Rate Negotiation Guide (2026)
Negotiate your indirect cost rate with 4 proven strategies. Learn cognizant agency rules, de minimis 15%, NICRA process, and statutory caps for 2026.
How to Calculate Indirect Costs for Federal Grants (2026)
Indirect costs = MTDC x your rate. Example: $330,000 MTDC at the 15% de minimis rate is $49,500 (10% on NIH awards). Formula, exclusions, worksheet.
2 CFR 200.404 Reasonable Costs: 5-Factor Test
Use the 5-factor 2 CFR 200.404 reasonable costs test, document price and policy evidence, and stop a federal grant charge when one factor is unresolved.
Cost Allocation Plan for Grants: 2 CFR 200 Guide
A cost allocation plan distributes shared costs across 2+ funding sources using 5 approved methods. Step-by-step guide with examples.
Grant Cost Sharing & Matching Requirements Guide
Many federal grants set a fixed match, such as 20% or 25%. Learn in-kind valuation, documentation rules, and 7 common matching pitfalls under 2 CFR 200.
What Is Cost Sharing in Grants? Match Explained
Cost sharing is the share of a grant project you pay. Only 8.7% of 867 open Grants.gov listings require it. See which programs do and what counts.